Oprah Winfrey has long been admired as a cultural icon, but recent events have put her under intense public scrutiny, revealing controversies and backlash surrounding her past decisions. This 600-word article explores the highlights of her career’s recent challenges, focusing on her role with Weight Watchers, a joint philanthropy with Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson, and her choice to withdraw from the Russell Simmons documentary.

The Weight Watchers Controversy

Oprah’s journey with Weight Watchers (now WW) began in 2015 when she bought a 10% stake and joined its board, bringing significant visibility and a revitalized image to the brand. However, in early 2024, Oprah announced her departure from the board and her decision to begin using a weight-loss medication in the GLP-1 agonist class, like Ozempic. While this class of medication is widely used for weight loss by reducing appetite and stabilizing blood sugar, Oprah’s decision sparked backlash, especially from loyal WW followers who viewed the medications as conflicting with the company’s ethos of lifestyle changes over pharmaceutical intervention.

Oprah defended her decision by emphasizing that obesity should be viewed as a chronic health condition rather than a willpower issue. Her advocacy for medication as a sustainable solution aimed to shift the stigma around weight-loss treatments, helping others see them as legitimate options for addressing long-term struggles. Despite her intentions, critics on social media accused her of hypocrisy, questioning why a long-time WW advocate would turn to weight-loss drugs.

The Maui Fund Backlash

In August 2023, Oprah and Dwayne Johnson launched the People’s Fund of Maui, intended to aid individuals who lost homes during the devastating Maui wildfires. The fund aimed to provide direct financial assistance, with Winfrey and Johnson donating an initial $10 million and calling on the public to join in their efforts. However, the initiative faced criticism on social media, with some feeling it was inappropriate for wealthy celebrities to solicit public donations when they could have contributed even more from their fortunes.

Responding to the backlash, Johnson expressed regret over the rollout and acknowledged that he could have introduced the fund more thoughtfully. He emphasized understanding the economic pressures people face, having once lived “paycheck to paycheck,” and wanted to ensure that the assistance reached those in need. Winfrey also responded, describing the criticism as a “vilifying” experience and expressing sympathy for those facing similar online challenges. She believed that the backlash distracted from the fund’s true purpose—providing aid to Maui residents.

The Russell Simmons Documentary Withdrawal

One of Oprah’s most controversial career decisions came in 2020 when she withdrew as the executive producer of On the Record, a documentary on sexual misconduct allegations against hip-hop mogul Russell Simmons. Directed by Kirby Dick and Amy Ziering, the film was set to premiere at the Sundance Film Festival with Oprah’s endorsement, but she unexpectedly withdrew, citing creative differences with the filmmakers. Winfrey voiced concerns about inconsistencies in the film’s narrative, stating it required additional work to fully represent the victims’ experiences.

Oprah’s decision ignited debate, with some questioning her withdrawal’s timing, given her outspoken support for sexual misconduct survivors. Her exit not only shocked the public but also led to the cancellation of the film’s Apple TV Plus distribution deal. While she maintained that her concerns were rooted in honoring the survivors’ stories, critics questioned whether external pressures influenced her decision, particularly as Simmons had publicly urged her to abandon the project.

Reflecting on Oprah’s Influence and Challenges

These recent controversies have cast a spotlight on Oprah’s complex role in navigating public perception, corporate influence, and personal convictions. Whether it’s defending weight-loss choices, managing philanthropy expectations, or navigating sensitive topics like misconduct, Oprah’s decisions reveal the delicate balance of her influence. She remains a significant voice, but these events show that even cultural icons are not immune to public scrutiny or controversy.

Through her responses to the criticism she faces, Oprah continues to engage with her audience, addressing questions about her intentions and the values she promotes. However, her experiences highlight the challenges that high-profile figures face in aligning personal choices with public image—a balancing act that remains central to her journey.

VIDEO: